TV Show: ★★★★ | Book: ★★

The Summer I Turned Pretty has been an annual summer-time series phenomenon. While the show hit No. 1 show on Amazon Prime following its Season 1 release, and its Season 2 is sure to hit the same, the books leave something to be desired.
Let’s start off with the classic caveat of, this book was originally released in 2009. It’s young adult. While I still read and enjoy young adult books, I feel no longer connected to the mindset of the characters and this has an overall impact on my reading experience.
Now back to the review. The book leaves something, a lot actually, to be desired. It’s what I would classify as a quick summer pool read with naive and young characters. Pool read is by no means a negative here, there are many types of pool reads and I enjoy many of them. In this case, you can read this book with no thoughts, head empty, and you’ll get the same out of it in the end as if you had been annotating and writing your dissertation on it. This is my personal opinion, if you disagree and loved the book, that’s great!

The TV Show on the other hand recognizes the missteps, flaws, and gaps in the book and builds upon it to make the hit show that it has become. There are still the bones, the story, the themes, but we’re getting a much deeper, richer story in the end. We see the strong female friendship of the mothers, the struggles of the teens and the adults, we get a more holistic experience. The book gave us bits and pieces, all from the perspective of a young girl, who is almost entirely unlikeable. In the show we see the raw struggles of dealing with such a heavy loss at pivotal teenage and young adult years, of losing both family and friend. It’s shown from all perspectives, multiple experiences intertwining to tell a story of different kinds of loss and recovery.

The book just didn’t have that. And again, it was written in a different era of teenage storytelling, it’s meant for a young audience than myself. But there are other stories, showcasing heavier topics to younger audiences, written in earlier times, that manage to tell this story in a stronger way. I’m glad the show saw these gaps, grew and expanded upon them to give us the moving picturew




